Aqua Smoky Extravagant Waterproof

Original was way better now low quality

Original was way better. Quantity of product has decreased and it runs out and dries out way too fast. The handle broke off right away… I hope the company is reading these reviews and making changes. Bring the original back!

Best waterproof mascara ever

I have been using this waterproof mascara for years and will not use anything else. I blink a lot and my eyes run but my mascara does not. After trying lots of mascaras with terrible results I finally found this one and will never buy another brand again.

Pleaseee bring back the original!

The original had been my only mascara for at least 10 years. People would ask if I had falsies on, it was that good. Like others, I tried this one when the original went out of stock. It's terrible. Why would you get rid of the original!? Please bring it back!

Can't compare to the original

The original was the best mascara I've ever used, hand down. This one leaves dark circles under my eyes after an hour of wear. Bring back the OG!!

Nope!

Not waterproof, bleeds on to eyelids after a few hours of wear. Doesn’t add much volume, brush shape is ridiculous. Now sad I bought it.

Grab this!

Excellent mascara and I’ve used a ton! I would highly recommend this mascara and I plan on ordering it again!

Lightweight formula, Amazing Wand!

I’ve been using this since 2013! I preferred the Original! I don’t find this one to be waterproof, just harder to remove! I do wish they would Bring the Original back! It’s the Only Mascara I’ve found to gives full and long Lashes!

Ugh! Bring back the original.

Noooooooo a bring back the original!!!! Nothing like it. Waterproof isn’t the same. I’m crying.

Bring back the original

Please bring back the non-waterproof version. As someone with oil-based tears (I found out from my eye doctor after lasic surgery) my eyes remove anything waterproof throughout the day simply by blinking. I’m left with black streaks under my eyes that resemble a football player!! 😫 Your brush is my favorite paired with the original formula. Please, please bring it back!

Raccoon Eyes, No Thanks!

Awful! Raccoon eyes, no thanks!! I wore the Original forever. Won’t be buying MUFE until everyone’s favorite mascara (smoky extravagant original) is back on the shelves. Moving on to other brands to find the perfect mascara.

Not for me - no volume, stubby lashes

This product does not build or add any volume. I returned it and went to another retailer to pick up Dior show.

Will always have in my drawer!

Love this mascara enough coverage and no smudging throughout day. Lasts 8 hrs!