By the Fireplace - Eau de Toilette

NO

It's absolutely dreadful! This has to be the worst perfume ever created—it's truly awful, haha!

sooooo yummy

my SIL recommended this to me so I checked it out while doing some Xmas shopping. Had one sniff and went straight to checkout with it. Has a bit of a boozy scent imo, which is my fav with gourmand perfumes. Very delicious, boozy, vanilla and nutty. I do also get a campfirey smell with it like the name suggests but in the best way. Once ive recovered from all my christmas shopping Ill definitely buy the full size because this will be my new everyday scent.

Great winter scent

Some of Maison's scents aren't great, but this one is the cake. It encapsulates a fire perfectly. Smokey, wintry, nutty.

Buy for my husband and steal it all. The. Time.

This is the ultimate holiday fragrance for me! I buy this for my husband and steal it all the time. It truly is smoky, musky yet not overpowering. It has great lasting effects and as it dies down, it gets even more personal. It truly transforms you to the depth of winter, cuddled up reading a book by the fireplace on a snow day. Get it!!

No no no

Honestly horrendous. Smells like burnt hair. Just awful.

If I had to choose one, this is it.

I've been using this scent for over a year and I choose it over every other bottle I have. It is a comforting scent to me. I get many compliments on it from both men and women!

Can’t get enough!

This scent grew on me. I ended up purchasing the refill and 3.4 oz set. So far the usage is noticeable in the bottle. Because its an eau de toilette the fragrance lightens up during the day or following day. However, it’s worth the pleast and lovely scent

Smells like a campfire+ burnt sugar

**I did not buy this, this was a free sample, and I mean that as in it was a tiny sample not that I was incentivized with a free product** The scent is okay? I do like it, don’t get me wrong it definitely does smell like a campfire but the problem is with the vanilla, it just smells like straight up burn sugar, and if it was meant to emulate toasted marshmallows I get that but it doesn’t smell like toasted marshmallows it smells like if you put sugar in a hot pan and let it burn. I’m sort of on the fence on whether I like it or not, while I like the earthy woody scent because it reminds me of camping, the burnt sugar scent is just really jarring.

Incredible fragrance

This is by far my favourite perfume! Smoky notes mixed with semi-sweet undertones makes for a perfect combination. It will not disappoint.

A very Cozy scent

This is my favorite scent from the Replica line! It smells so cozy and warm. It’s one of my favorite vanilla scents! I layer it with Finry sweet on the outside.

Comforting cozy smoky gourmand scent

I love this. Bought as a blind buy. My travel size doesn't smell as strong as a sample I received after I ordered so I have to spray more.. It is such a comforting scent with vanilla, campfire smoke and marshmallows. Definitely going to get a bigger bottle

LOVE

Absolutely love this I purchased the gift set it smells so good it’s my new go to I also purchased for my sister because it’s that good highly recommend it has such a good balance of vanilla and chestnut.